The fastest way to increase average order value on Shopify is a post-purchase upsell: an offer shown or emailed immediately after checkout, when the customer has already paid and there is no friction left to add. Typical lift is 5–15% AOV. The next-best levers are a free-shipping threshold set about 20–30% above your current AOV, product bundles, and AI-personalised recommendations based on what the customer actually bought rather than static 'related products'.
Key facts
- Post-purchase upsell: 5–15% AOV lift, no risk to checkout conversion.
- Free shipping threshold set 20–30% above current AOV: 3–8% lift.
- Bundles and volume discounts: 5–10% lift on the products they cover.
- Raising AOV is cheaper than raising traffic — no ad spend is required.
- Pre-checkout upsells can reduce conversion; post-checkout ones cannot.
Step by step
- 1. Measure your baseline
Shopify Analytics → Average order value, last 90 days. Everything is measured against this number.
- 2. Add a post-purchase offer
Immediately after the order is placed, offer one complementary product — not a cheaper version of what they just bought.
- 3. Set a free-shipping threshold
Set it 20–30% above AOV and show progress in the cart drawer.
- 4. Bundle what is already bought together
Use Shopify's order data to find real co-purchase pairs instead of guessing.
- 5. Follow up by email
A 24–72 hour post-purchase email with one personalised recommendation converts while the brand is still fresh.
Why post-purchase beats pre-purchase
Every element you add before payment is a chance to lose the sale. A post-purchase offer sits after the money has moved: worst case the customer ignores it and your conversion rate is untouched, best case you add margin to an order you already won.
The offer has to be complementary, not competitive. Someone who just bought a serum should be offered the moisturiser, not a bigger bottle of the same serum at a discount — that only devalues the purchase they just made.
Personalisation is what separates 3% from 15%
A static 'best sellers' block converts poorly because it ignores what the customer just told you with their money. Recommendations built from the actual line items in the order, the customer's past orders and your live catalog convert several times better.
Reorbit is a Shopify app that automates this end to end: it reads your live catalog and order history, writes each email with AI, sends it at the right moment, and attributes recovered revenue back to real Shopify orders. Plans are flat from $4.99/month with a 14-day free trial.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good average order value for a Shopify store?
It is entirely category-dependent — a supplements store might sit at $45 and a furniture store at $900. The useful benchmark is your own trend: AOV should rise quarter over quarter as you add upsells, bundles and thresholds.
Do upsells hurt conversion rate?
Pre-checkout upsells can, because they add friction before payment. Post-purchase upsells shown after the order is placed cannot reduce conversion, which is why they are the safest place to start.
What is the fastest way to increase AOV?
Turn on a post-purchase upsell email or offer. It requires no ad spend, no theme changes and no new products, and typically lifts AOV 5–15% within the first month.
Related
Last updated 2026-08-01 · Written by the Reorbit team · All answers